Monday, November 29, 2021

The Big One


I've mentioned before that when I originally started this blog it was with the intention of posting the 30 or so rare albums that I had collected over the years and then to perhaps add one or two every few months, but scale it down. The recent Earl Slick post was actually my one thousandth post, so something's gone a bit wrong somewhere. The first couple of years were fun, learning how blogs worked and posting the albums, hitting one million visitors, starting the '...and on guitar' series, and getting to know like-minded music fans along the way. Then, a year ago I started to receive take-down notices from Warners, and before long they were coming in too fast for me to keep up with, and then on Boxing Day 2020 the blog was deleted. I wasn't sure if I wanted to carry on with it, as if I did then I couldn't post links or the same thing would just happen again, and I remembered that Paul at albumsthatshouldexist had recommended an app called Soulseek, where you could store your music and it was fairly safe from prying eyes, so I decided to give that a try. Little did I know the trouble that would cause, as despite coming up with a way that only my albums would show in a search, some people just couldn't get it to work, and despite offering to send direct links, visitors started to drop off alarmingly. That was also because instead of having to visit every page and click the link, you only had to visit the site once, make a note of the albums you wanted, and then get them from Soulseek later. In fact, one user has just set the new record for downloads in one go, with over 250 albums being requested at the same time. Hopefully he'll let me know what he thinks of them once he's listened to them. Despite the continuation of the disappointing lack of feedback I'm going to soldier on, as despite the setbacks over the past year, I do still enjoy finding or constructing these rare albums. I'd love to find a way to post links again, and I could try leaving them in the comments, but I'd want to know how the records companies find them first, and would that hide them? It must start with bots, but once you're on their radar does someone then just go through the whole blog and send hundreds of emails to Blogger? If anyone has had the same experience, or knows how they work I'd love to hear. 

UPDATE

It was worth posting this request for ideas about takedowns, as Mike S mentioned something that lit a bulb in my head, and it occurred to me that Paul has only ever had a couple of takedowns, and they didn't then target him later, so I reckon it is the fact that he posts the whole link as text rather then as a hyperlink, and I think that hides it from the bots, so I'll give that a go over December and we'll see how it goes. I'll still post to Soulseek as a backup. 
            

37 comments:

  1. Congrats on the thousandth post. More importantly, thank you for all you do for all of us. can't add anything regarding the bots, but will share that I have found Soulseek a great solution once I got used to it.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I want to pitch in by saying thank you for all the hard work you do on this blog. The Al Stewart comps were the icing on the cake for me. I don't download much but I do enjoy reading the information you provide which is often a treasure trove of facts unknown to me. Just wanted to say thanks.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Thank you for all your hard work. I appreciate your responses when I ask for a link because I just can't get SoulSeek to work. It's a technical reason and I have no workaround.
    I appreciate the time and effort and hope you continue

    ReplyDelete
  4. Whew! Until the climax, you had me expecting a different denoument. What a great mystery writer you are! And I'm glad you're continuing. (Although he's usually a bass player, would P McCartney be available for your "And on guitar" series? In know that he was with Steve Miller on Brave New World, as "Paul Ramon," and of course he appeared occasionally with other ex-Beatles, but I don't know if he made a habit of it.)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Great idea "... And on guitar ... Paul McCartney". A wonderful and underrated guitarist. I think it would be difficult to find him on guest guitar. Maybe on some of his brothers stuff? You'll probably find him more often guesting on drums or bass.

      Delete
    2. I too thought this post was leading up to an announcement of your retirement from music blogging. I enjoy your writing and admire your work ethic, your creativity and your diverse musical tastes. Glad to see that you are keeping it up!

      Delete
    3. I've gone through McCartney's guest appearances up to 1991 and have found about four on guitar - two for his brother - so looks like he's off the series.

      Delete
  5. Love your blog
    Not all music is to my taste but always a good read.
    Looking forward to the next 1000

    ReplyDelete
  6. Thanks for all the hard work you put into this. The transfer to Soulseek does make it a bit harder to access, at least for me, but I still do follow and very much appreciate all the work you do and the amazing content.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Hey there. I am the above-mentioned downloader and I feel like a real shit heel and I'm so so very sorry. I just want you to know that I've been reading and following your amazing page for a very long time. I literally check in nightly as one of the first things I do when I start my evening. The reason for that glut of downloads has mostly to do with being overwhelmed by how much amazing stuff you post and how totally intrigued I am by your write ups. It's long been a to do list for me to just download as I go and as you post but as you can see I've clearly been very very lax on that. Some of that, a lot of it, has to do with storage space. I recently pulled the trigger on some external hard drives that have allowed me to load many things, I think of it, honestly, like an animal squirreling away food for the winter, to be slowly enjoyed over time. I spend most of my nights, all night, just listening to albums and catching up on things so I assure you these aren't just gluttony. I've been so looking forward to being able to take in all these albums I've read you profile on this blog for so long that I guess I sort of uh, yeah went whole hog in a rude and insensitive way. I apologize again, from the bottom of my heart. The last thing I want to do is abuse the hard and inspiring work that you do here. It keeps me going. I follow a bunch of sites that do this format but yours in one of the only ones that I watch this closely and that never disappoints. You've reintroduced me to so many albums in so many interesting ways and given me fresh eyes on things I've lived with my whole life and it's just such a gift. I am famously bad at communicating. Ask anyone in my family. And that's my own character flaw to bear. I'm sorry that it's come into your orbit. No excuses here. All I can say is that I am an ardent follower of your work and i've been reading for a long time and waiting to hear so much of it and I bring you up in every conversation with anyone of any sort of music enthusiast DNA. It's sort of my winter goal to go through all these albums I downloaded a few each night and listen and go back and reread the posts for them. Feels like a good way to spend the cold dark nights. I'm rambling. This is just again to say I am so so sorry and I mean NO disrespect and that download glut was done out of obsession and enjoyment for and of your work. It feels awful to be called out "by name" here but I certainly earned that. Though if you wanted to change that to something more anonymous... I'd be less mortified I guess. I'm relieved and inspired that despite all the label hassle you're going to push on. A lot of us out here, this is our medicine.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi there. Apology accepted, and once you've listened to the albums I'd love the hear what you think of them. It might even give me ideas for new posts, as suggestions are always welcome. It was a random comment that inspired the Al Stewart posts, and they have been really popular. It was just that I'd never seen to mant downloads at one time, so it was a bit of a surprise. I'll anonymise your name in the name to restore your self-esteem!

      Delete
  8. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  9. You are a consummate gentleman and professional. It really means a lot to hear back from you and for you to make that change/gesture. I've devoured a bunch of them already, sort of willy-nilly as they came in but my plan is to reread each post as I listen to each one and hopefully have something interesting to respond or, if nothing else, some well-deserved praise. I love that you're open to ideas from us out here. I know there are legions of people with ideas about what if this or that or just different takes on well known albums. A good friend of mine and I have been making a little project based around how important sequencing of tracks is for an album and how hearing something in the wrong order, no matter how amazing or classic the album is, reduces it to head-scratching nonsense. I like to do this thing I call the "mix-off", basically when you and a buddy love a band with a big enough catalog you make a best of disc for them like a competition but it isn't. It's just to see what a band you love looks like to someone else you know. The whole thing has a bunch of little rules (it can't start or end with any song that starts or ends an album, etc etc). Anyway we were working on, haha, GNR Use Your Illusion 1/2 as one album and that turned into trying to make the most frustrating listener not-friendly version of that. If I'm making sense as I rapid fire all this. Anyway that spurred into thinking about stone classic albums and how if you did the segues and track lists differently they never would have been much of a such. It's amazing how little it takes to make something as back to front cohesive and ineffable as like, Revolver by the Beatles, completely frustrating and unsatisfying. ANYWAY, that's me on a tangent and not here or there. Mostly just my mind firing on formats and suggestions. Of all the blogs out there that do this you seem to be the most consistent and have by miles the most output and over many ideas, lost albums, alternates, different track list ideas, archives. These are the kinds of things I spend way too much time musing over. But yes if I come up with any suggestions I'll hit you up and I'll try to keep notes going as I listen to all this stuff and give you my impressions on your hard work. Thank you again for being so gracious. Much love.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Don't give up! Your blog us one of the first I go to every morning!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Don't worry, I'm not giving up, but the Friday posts might drop as I use up the albums that are ready to go.

      Delete
  11. I visit this site everyday and was one of the inspirations to start making my own albums I wish I existed for my website. Keep up the good work

    ReplyDelete
  12. I can't say that I have downloaded as much as POLTERGEIST but I have downloaded a number of high quality "Albums I Wish Existed" - I love the metaphor of squirreling away your ideas until I have a chance to listen. I have been introduced to a number of new artists - and re-introduced to others that I was already aware of. I loved your series of Faces and early Fleetwood Mac compilations. I visit and peruse your blog daily (often several times). Thanks for all your efforts - I'm impressed that you accomplish so much editing and compiling this material. Thanks and please don't stop!

    ReplyDelete
  13. Forgot to say CONGRATULATIONS on reaching the 1K mark. Your response to Poltergeist was very kind, and goes to show that above all, you are a fan who enjoys sharing with other fans.

    Wish I knew enough about Blogger, bots, and DMCA notices to answer your questions. Some file sharers use character substitution to outwit the bots (e.g., "B0b Dy1àn"), especially for well-known artists who are more likely to have legal representation.

    This is a fascinating article about copyright enforcement (and the history of the concert film Urgh! A Music War). The story involves Youtube, but the author is a music blogger (www.lostturntable.com).

    https://medium.com/@jameseldred/my-new-wave-youtube-copyright-nightmare-73c0bc8e2d61

    ReplyDelete
  14. At first I bitched about SoulSeek but with a little bit of time I figured it out. Now I can't help but sing the praises of SoulSeek they have tons of hard to find things. Which got me thinking are there any sites out there that take requests of things others can't find? I'm trying to find a Captain Beefheart thing that from what I'm reading only had a pressing of about 200. It's this
    https://www.discogs.com/release/2660126-Captain-Beefheart-And-The-Magic-Band-Zappa-Commemorative-Set-1972-1975-With-Bonus
    Anyway when I start my mornings there are sites I check on, this is one of them. Love this site. Was wondering if maybe there's a Dave Stewart/Jeff Lynn compilation brewing?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I've had a look around the the Beefheart/Zappa set but can't find it anywhere, so I think you're out of luck on that one.

      Delete
  15. Fantastic blog, soulseek is great, no problems at all.

    ReplyDelete
  16. It took a couple of tries, but I understand how to search on Soulseek, and it works fine. I really enjoy your posts and am delighted you will continue this site. Thanks for all you do.

    ReplyDelete
  17. First: Congratulations on your milestone!
    Second: Until you get sick of it (and maybe even longer than that, I will continue to suggest "... And on bass ... John Wetton" ...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I've pestering him for and "and on Sax...Bobby Keyes" and i'm not even a big fan of the sax. It's just that Keys was on so many great songs. He deserves not to be forgotten.

      Delete
  18. Don't give up, your blog is one of the few I can count on and I check it out each day. Thank you for everything you have done and continue to do. You are appreciated more than you realize!

    ReplyDelete
  19. It´s a terrific blog despite there is a lot I am not interested in. BUT... what I am interested in, is seriously interesting. Soulseek works in general very good for me (except when it doesn't and usually I don't really know why) ...

    Suggestions? How about some cool mid 1980´s David Lindley, Steve Forbert (I still miss a bunch of his self released albums which are not available anymore), Son Volt, Black Crowes (to mention a few). But whatever you are going to do, I will be very happy to find it. Thx

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I have a Black Crowes in the offing, so watch out for that.

      Delete
  20. Congratulations on #1000!
    sometimes Soulseek doesn't let me access your uploads on the day uploaded but it usually works within 24 hours.. so it's cool.. your creativity and hard work is appreciated!

    ReplyDelete
  21. Congrats with number 1000. A search on Soulseek on the name of the artist + aiwe ususually is enough to get there (when you are connected; and otherwise I just try the day after).

    ReplyDelete
  22. Hi PJ. I am a frequent visitor to your blog. I have loved music since i was a child. A transistor radio tuned to fm top 40 put me to bed each night then. I don't often download what you post but i read your blogs and if something catches my eye i will look for a flac version of the artist. Andwella's Dream is currently on my playlist because of your post. I am also a fan of the and on guitar series because you have curated the artists work and selected a broad body of their work. Since these are often collaborations with other artists it open my eyes to new sounds. I'm always looking for new sounds. I have that malody which so many music lover share. Thank you for your work and i want you to know you are appreciated even if it doesn't always show in downloads.

    ReplyDelete
  23. Paul here, from the albumsthatshouldexist blog. Please don't stop! Your blog is great. And you're right, I've only had one take-down notice so far, due to posting Tom Petty material. Maybe I've been astoundingly lucky compared to you, but that doesn't seem likely, especially since I probably post more from "big name" artists than you do. So maybe that's something about how I post things that doesn't draw the interest of the bots as much?

    ReplyDelete
  24. Amazing job with your 1000 posts. I download a lot of your posts, but seldom leave comments...sorry...the main problem seems to be that I am collecting faster than I have time to listen, and by the time I listen, it seems like old news....but let me tell you, your blog and ATSE are the best blogs on the internet as far as I'm concerned, You are not only making rare music available, you are cleaning them up and organising them, often creating LPs better than the artists original LPs. On the subject of soulseek, just one problem....it's addictive, and once you work out how to use it (by trial and error (minimal documentation)) and learn which users are friendly and which are not, it's an amazing resource. Thanks for all the hard work.

    ReplyDelete
  25. Congratulations on the thousandth post and, thank you for all the effort you put in to bring these bands and tracks to us. Soulseek was a little strange to begin with but once I got used to it, it seemed like a great solution for you not losing everything that you’ve worked so hard to achieve.
    You got me feeling guilty! I’m pretty sure that I haven’t downloaded as many as 250 in one go but I certainly was pretty close when I first discovered your blog and like Poltergeist, I’ve squirrelled them away (for fear of your blog closing down) to slowly work my way through them at a more reasonable pace.
    I visit your blog every day, excited that there may be something posted that I’ve never heard of or never considered listening to previously. Your diverse collection is exactly what I’ve achieved during 50 years of collecting music. I enjoy reading the information you provide, which is often a wonderful collection of interesting facts unknown to me. You and Paul, over at albumsthatshouldexist have led me into searching the net and creating my own CDs of obscure tracks, which are never anywhere as good as yours but they keep me happy.
    Thank you again and long may you continue.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Help yourself to as many albums as you like. I only mentioned the 250 downloads as before that the most that I'd seen was around 40, so it just stood out!

      Delete
  26. Congrats on #1000.
    Thanks for all of the interesting music on here.

    ReplyDelete
  27. Wow 1000! I can't begin to express how thankful I am for the hard work you put in here. This is truly an excellent blog in which I'm constantly looking forward to.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. PJ I've been combing through your old reviews at your Peter Jolly site and just wanted to thank you you for all your work! Thanx Bunches!!!

      Delete