Genesis - The Lamb Lies Down On Broadway (Early Version) (1974)

Time for another guest post from Mike Solof, and this time it's an alternative look at one of both his and my favourite albums of all time.

I've always loved Genesis and all their various group versions (except for the last album without Collins… who the heck is Ray Wilson??) But 'Lamb...' always held a special place in my heart. I recently got a hold of Highland's great compilation of all the different outtakes available from the album, and although it was a cool listen it was repetitive at times, and still missing some cuts. So I decided to go through all the different versions included in their set and try to edit together a complete alternate version made of the best cuts and segments of cuts from all the demo's available. To do this I had to mix together early takes, demo’s, alternate mixes, and the occasional live track here and there to fill in the missing gaps, as I figured the live tracks were the closest I could come to including an "alternate version".  I really liked the way this turned out and made three different versions. The first was just a pretty seamless entire album version. The second was a 5 part segmented version where each "suite" was separated at the parts that didn’t really mix well into the next, usually because the early takes sound very different from the alternate demo mixes of the finished takes. As much as possible I tried to use the early takes over everything else because they are so unique and different. The third and final version I made up was each track presented as an individual track. This was my least favourite version as some tracks had rough beginnings and ending and worked much better when gently mixed into the next track using fade ins and fade outs. Once I had the whole thing edited to my liking… I turned to my friend CaptainAcid for help with remastering this to sound as best it could. It is my first team-up on remastering and I really appreciate all his help. He helped me touch up about 80% of the whole album and those bits and pieces sound magnificent! THANKS CAPTAIN!! Then, after much discussion with pj we decided to go with posting the full, unedited, one track, complete version for... THE FLOW! (It’s all about The Flow baby!). On most cuts the vocals were very low in the mix so I used modern tech to raise them so you can now here all of Peter's imperceptible, incoherent and unintelligible mumblings in gorgeous clarity, lol, you can thank me later!!) If anyone would like the other versions just drop a note in the comment section and I will gladly provide them, Attention Hound that I am!) 

PS If you'd like to hear and see another fun version of this album, check out this YouTube video by another favourite artist of mine Kevin Gilbert! Kevin was a huge Genesis fan and was actually being considered to take over for Collins. It's really rather a tragic story, as when Kevin’s manager found out that Kevin was on the short list as Collin’s replacement he rushed over to Kevin’s house to tell him, only to find Kevin had accidentally killed himself at his home. But here is a link to Kevin (and Giraffe, his incredible back-up band!) performing 'The Lamb; almost in it's entirety, and it’s just FREAKING BRILLIANT! Ahhh…what might have been, but that's a story I'll save for a possible Kevin Gilbert post I'm considering doing here! (Let me know if you’d like that in the comments!) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9-RtfxuX3Co.

It's always my pleasure to present the various incarnations of Genesis in new and different ways, like this one posted on Paul's site recently   https://albumsthatshouldexist.blogspot.com/2021/05/genesis-acoustic-evening-with-genesis.html

So here is the track listing of what I ended up using from the 2 LP Highland set.

Track listing

01 The Lamb Lies Down On Broadway (take 1)
02 Fly On A Windshield (take 1)
03 Broadway Melody Of 1974 (live)
04 Cuckoo Cocoon (different mix demo 1)
05 In The Cage (take 3 and demo mix)
06 The Grand Parade Of Lifeless Packaging (different mix demo 3)
07 Back In N.Y.C. (take 1 and demo mix 3) 
08 Hairless Heart (unnumbered early take)
09 Counting Out Time (take 1)
10 The Carpet Crawlers (live)
11 The Chamber Of 32 Doors (take 1)
12 Lilywhite Lilith
13 Drum Solo - Waiting Room (different mix demo)
14 Anyway (different mix demo)
15 Here Comes The Supernatural Anesthetist (take 1 -demo with Phil on vocals)
16 The Lamia (take 2)
17 Silent Sorrow In Empty Boats (live)
18 The Colony Of Slipperman (Arrival / A Visit To The Doktor / Raven) (take 5)
19 Ravine (live)
20 The Light Dies Down On Broadway (unnumbered early take)
21 Unused Instrumental Intro - Riding The Scree (different mix demo)
22 In The Rapids / It (take 2)

I hope you enjoy this rare peek behind the curtain at Genesis recording their most brilliant album in their catalogue.

Michael

PPS… as always, there is a lot more background info around - here are three great articles on the making of this stunning prog rock masterpiece!

https://classicrockreview.wordpress.com/2013/05/18/genesis-the-demo-mix-down-on-broadway/

https://en.apoplife.nl/in-1974-genesis-releases-the-masterful-the-lamb-lies-down-on-broadway/

https://www.loudersound.com/features/genesis-i-was-aware-there-was-something-going-on-with-peter

For my part I just made the cover, which I wanted to keep as close to the iconic original as possible, so I decided just to colourize the original artwork. pj